CCL:G: Confusing issue of Raman intensity Vs Static polarizability

 Sent to CCL by: "Mi  Yang" [miyang3790~~gmail.com]
 Dear Kzys!!
 Yes I am a gaussian03 Rev user but Your comments a bit confusing for me as in
 G03 manual it is clearly mentioned that by using Freq=Raman you can
 "Compute Raman intensities in addition to IR intensities" so I am not
 understanding ur point of view.
 http://www.gaussian.com/g_ur/k_freq.htm
 There are some good quality of publications where they show computed raman
 intensities with gaussian e.g.
  J. AM. CHEM. SOC. 2005, 127, 10977-10981.pdf
 http://homepage.univie.ac.at/Ferenc.Simon/publications/2005/Schaman_KBproc2005.pdf
 So I have stoped my work and first want to confirm it.
 Secondly, my calculated Freq value of Raman spectrum is in good agreement  to
 the experimental value for specific mode of vibrations after scaling. I am not
 comparing directlt intensity with intensity.My purpose is to show increase of
 intensity or activity upon intercalation of metal atom.What do you think in this
 regard?
 I need your comments in detail especially in view of above references
 > "zborowsk]|[chemia.uj.edu.pl"  wrote:
 >
 > Sent to CCL by: zborowsk**chemia.uj.edu.pl
 >
 > >
 > > Sent to CCL by: favaro [laurent.favaro[#]u-psud.fr]
 > > Do you mean that G03 does not calculate Raman Cross-section ?
 > > I believe you are wrong.
 >
 > Gaussian calculates Raman Activities, not Raman Intensities, and obviously
 > it is not the same. Raman Activities cannot be compared directly with
 > experimental Raman spectra.
 >
 > Regards
 >
 > Kzys
 >
 > > Regards.
 > > LF
 > >
 > > zborowsk]*[chemia.uj.edu.pl a crit :
 > >> Sent to CCL by: zborowsk|,|chemia.uj.edu.pl
 > >> Hi
 > >> Dear Mi Yang
 > >> I want to warn you if you are Gaussian user.
 > >> Gaussian does not calculate  Raman Intensities
 > >>
 > >>
 > >>
 > >> Sent to CCL by: favaro [laurent.favaro|*|u-psud.fr]
 > >>  Raman intensity is related to the square
 > >>  of the derivative of polarizability with respect
 > >>  to the normal coordinates of the vibrationnal mode.
 > >>  Best regards,
 > >>  Dr Favaro
 > >>  Mi Yang miyang3790_+_gmail.com a crit :
 > >>
 > >>  Sent to CCL by: "Mi  Yang" [miyang3790*gmail.com]
 > >>  Dear CCL users,
 > >>  I need some comments or refs about my problem. I am studying the
 > >> interaction of a metal with a boron cluster. I found the large
 increase
 > >> of static polarizability and hyperpolarizability upon interaction
 of
 > >> metal atom to that boron cluster. I also calculated the Raman
 spectrum
 > >> which also showed high increase of intensity in metal boron
 cluster. I
 > >> read some indirect relationship b/m these two properties but now
 in
 > >> spite
 > >> of my best efforts I could not find the direct relationship
 between
 > >> Static polarizability and Raman intensity. Anybody who knows any
 ref or
 > >> comments about this relationship (Static
 > >> polarizability/hyperpolarizability and Raman intensity) would be
 highly
 > >> appreciated.?
 > >>  Miyang
 > >>  P.R.China>
 > >
 > >
 >
 >
 > --
 > Krzysztof Zborowski
 > Faculty of Chemistry
 > Jagiellonian University
 > 3 Ingardena Street
 > 30-060 Krakow
 > Poland
 > phone: +48(12)632-4888 ext. 2064 or 2067
 > fax:  +48(12)634-05-15
 > email: zborowsk###chemia.uj.edu.pl
 > gg 3817259
 > skype kzys70
 > www.chemia.uj.edu.pl/~zborowsk
 >
 >